Friday, January 19, 2007

Pan's Labrynth (or, El laberinto del fauno)

Of the triumvirate of Mexican directors taking the world by storm at the moment Guillermo del Toro is certainly the most fantastical. He already has two comic book flicks (Hellboy and Blade II) under his belt along with some other big budget Hollywood fright-fests off the strength of his debut, Cronos. Up until now though, I would have said my favourite of his works was the Spanish gothic-horror The Devil's Backbone. Up until now.

Now I'd have to think about it.

Del Toro's new film, Pan's Labyrinth shares much with its younger brother. Both are set against a backdrop of the Spanish Civil War; both are seen through the eyes of young children in overwhelming situations; and both dip deeply into the world of grotesque, highly-stylised fantasy.

It is that same tried and true story, girl travels with her pregnant mother to remote outpost to be with her new "father" while he hunts down republican guerillas, only to discover that she is really the princess of an underground world. How many times have we heard that one before?

Don't be put off, or dismayed, but the majority of the story takes place in the "real" world. Ofelia's struggle to come to terms with her new life (both real and fantastical) is paralleled by the the struggle of the housekeeper, Mercedes to support her brother and the rebels in the surrounding hills. Maribel Verdu is excellent (yes she has managed to rip herself free from that sex sandwich double dance in Y Tu Mama Tambien to grace the screen again). Actually, all of the cast is top notch but Verdu is a standout.

The beauty of Pan's Labyrinth is that it is not a fairy tale for kiddies. Guillermo is a geek, through and through, so this is more of a masturbatory outing for adults whose inner children have grown up into little freaks. It is gory, at times look-away-from-the-screen gory. The fantasy scenes are quite creepy, especially the monster at the feast.

It isn't a perfect film. The pacing is a little off, there are some unmotivated plot developments and many have criticised the lack of more direct parallels between the two storylines. I can understand the concerns but for me it didn't detract too much from the film as a whole.

Done! See it!

Now, let's get geeky: who would win in a fight between Pan's Labyrinth and The Devil's Backbone? Hmm. It's a tight match. There'd be two pulpy messes after the bout but I think that The Devil's Backbone would probably win out because it had just a little bit more texture and menace to it. Certainly don't let that stop you from seeing this film. I'd recommend it wholeheartedly.

Labels: , , ,

6 Comments:

At 1:19 pm, Blogger cloudcontrol said...

I saw this at a preview screening about a month ago, and I've been raving like a lunatic about it ever since.

I have to say, howewver, the plot did seem to be a little disappointing after having seen the preview online, but the mood and styling more than make up for that, in my mind. I've never been one who couldn't be swayed by a pound of style when an ounce of substance was missing, however.

How amazingly creepy was the monster with the hands?

But in the final analysis, I think that the Devil's Backbone is definitely better, because it keeps a firmer foot in the real (being more of a magic-realism-thriller type than a fantasy-horror) but that could be a sub-genre-based preference on my part.

 
At 7:43 am, Blogger MadeInScotland said...

as with so many other movies. I'd love to see it. Heard nothing but good...but I realise now I have a fear of the cinema. It's too public. And how the audience talk. So i ahve to wait til DVD release.

See you anon

ahoj

Oh, yes-my point. Brothers Grimm. Grimm. Watched it over 2 nights spread 5 nights apart then deleted it before completion. But I did like the accents.

As for the Vampire qui suce...well still got to "suck" that to completion sometime.

Hey, leave me a comment sometime!

AA..ahoj

 
At 5:31 am, Blogger Viasm said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 
At 5:34 am, Blogger Viasm said...

You spelled Labyrinth wrong throughout your post. You can see that it's spelled correctly on the .gif of the movie poster you have at the beginning of your blog.

 
At 8:42 am, Blogger walypala said...

Thanks. All fixed (I think) - though I did leave the title misspelled in honour of your help.

 
At 9:15 am, Blogger Paul Martin said...

Pan's Labyrinth is visually much more compelling than Devil's Backbone, though for me, narrative is more important, so the latter is a better film.

I had three problems with Pan's Labyrinth: (1) the level of violence was unnecessarily sadistic, alienating some of the audience, (2) the reality layer of the film was too caricatured, detracting from its attempt to portray reality, (3) certain contrivances such as Ofelia eating the grapes seemed too implausible.

So, at the end of the day, I don't think Pan's Labyrinth will pass the test of time like the much more subtle and reflective The Spirit of the Beehive (El Espiritu de la Colmena, 1973) has, which appears to be at least partically inspiration for Pan's Labyrinth. It is also about a girl who fantasises about a monster which is overlaid in the context of Franco's fascist Spain.

Feel free to check out my review.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home