Saturday, April 01, 2006

CONSPIRACY... Conspiracy... conspiracy... cons...

I love a good conspiracy theory as much as the next man, woman or child and this is one that I love.

Did the Americans manufacture the attack on the Twin Towers and the Pentagon?

The file clocks in at almost an hour and a half so if you want to watch it I would suggest downloading it from Google Video rather than streaming it (just click on the film box below).



Many of the details you have probably heard before. Does the argument have any merit? It does seem hard to deny that something untoward is going on given the mountain of circumstances that the filmmaker documents. While that is all interesting and thought provoking in itself (these tangled and convoluted conspiracy plots make for good pub banter), something in this text sparked my interest beyond the outlandishness of the claims.

Early in the film there is a brief mention of a neoconservative think tank attended by Donald Rumsfeld, Dick Cheney and Paul Wolfowitz where they state that "...the process of transformation, even if it brings revolutionary change, is likely to be a long one, absent some catastrophic and catalizing event - like a new Pearl Harbor." This immediately put me in mind of the BBC documentary "The Power Of Nightmares", which argues that the American neo-consevatives (spearheaded by Rumsfeld, Cheney adn Wolfowitz) deliberately blew the terrorist threat out of proportion in order to manipulate the American psyche.

"The Power of Nightmares" places the rise of the neoconservatives and radical Islamists into a compelling historical context. Both "movements" grew out of a reaction to what they saw as the failure of American liberalism in the late 1950s. The neoconservatives saw the state disintergrating into anarchy and theorised that the only way to stem this degradation was to manufacture an enemy, an ideological counterpoint, for America to rally against. And so, the film theorises, the embers of the "Cold War" were fanned.

The documentary tracks the influence of the neoconservatives in American politics through to the present day and how they managed to creat and nurture their enemies (including the radical Islamists) for their own political and ideological ends. It makes for compelling viewing though it can be a little heavy handed and repetitive over its three one-hour episodes. After watching ask yourself the question again:

Did the Americans manufacture the attack on the Twin Towers and the Pentagon?

You can download all the overblown "goodness" of "The Power of Nightmares here.

Tags: , , , , ,

4 Comments:

At 8:43 pm, Blogger D said...

Neo-conservatives have obviously capitalised enormously on the 9/11 (or is 11/9 for us following the british dating system?) terrorist attacks, just as they progressed their argument for pre-emptive foreign policy, after the attack on the USS Cole, and the first WTC bombing (which arguments were given short-shrift by Clinton, who people forget had a brain as well as a penis).

To somehow conclude that they therefore "manufactured" the 9/11 attacks is just bollocks.

This is almost as bad as the recent "documentary" channel 10 screened, which alleged there weren't passenger jets involved, and that no attack occured on the Pentagon.

These are all just distractions from the main issue, which I see as being the completely incompetent way the US has responded to violent islamist extremism.

All else is just smoke and mirrors.

 
At 9:48 pm, Blogger walypala said...

Never mind the bollocks. It wouldn't be a good conspiracy theory if it wasn't bollocks!

Do check out "The Power Of Nightmares" though. It is quite interesting to see how the complete incompetence of U.S. foreign policy is often not as incompetent as it seems.

Do beware though, it is not well made and it uses a good deal of atmospherics to hammer home its point.

 
At 11:38 am, Blogger D said...

Their ideology may be consistent, but in my opinion it is still grossly incompetent. I saw "Nightmares" but I'd recommend "Why We Fight" which takes an even broader view (than simply questioning neo-conservatism) to explain US military/foreign policy.

 
At 1:06 pm, Blogger walypala said...

I shall check out "Why We Fight". It looks interesting.

Did you find that "Nightmares" seemed to drum home the same message with the same words about three or four times each episode? I found it rather annoying by the end of the third installment.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home